The question of the identity of Spirits

Paulo Degering R Jr
image_pdfimage_print

Translations, from Portuguese, are automatic. If you notice any errors in the text, help us identify them, clicking here.

Subscribe to our Newsletters and receive our articles directly in your email.

Views: 1,054
image_pdfimage_print

This question was developed in response to a message attributed to Allan Kardec in the introduction to the book "Spiritism is the Work of Jesus," by Paulo Henrique de Figueiredo and other authors:

Follow the path I have walked. Yes, there was pain, fear, setbacks, and obstacles. But nothing stopped me; moreover, they encouraged me and strengthened my determination. Each of us, at a certain point in our journey, will experience the ultimate test, the true fulfillment, where we find our worth in serving our Creator with dedication and humility. Yesterday it was me, tomorrow it will be each of you. The worlds wait in eternity for the light to show the way. The light of the world was Jesus; I only repeated his words. Together we serve at God's command. Come and be part of this resplendent celebration. The times have come. Just keep moving forward.

Allan Kardec

Psychographed page written on September 12, 2025.

Mateus mediumistic group.

“"If we were to summon Kardec and a Spirit, claiming to be Kardec, were to deliver an elevated, moral message, without delving any deeper into it, would it be important to ascertain the identity of that Spirit? What did Kardec demonstrate regarding this type of situation?"”

This is a question that touches on the core of Allan Kardec's method for discerning spiritual communications, especially when it comes to elevated moral teachings.

According to Allan Kardec, in the scenario you describe — where a Spirit presents itself with a respectable name (like his) and brings a elevated message, of a moral nature. — a absolute identity of that Spirit would be a secondary issue and of no real importance..

Below is what Kardec demonstrated and taught about this situation, prioritizing the value of the content over the name.

1. The Priority of Moral Content

Kardec established a fundamental rule for judging communications, applicable when instruction is the main focus:

• What matters is the nature of the teaching.Whether it is good or bad, worthy or unworthy of the person who signs it. This is the crucial issue.

• The name It's never a guarantee.. The only true guarantee of superiority is thought and the way in which it is expressed.

• If the teaching is good and rational, It matters little what name the Spirit takes.

• For general instructions, if the Spirit only says useful things, The name by which it reveals itself is irrelevant. Often, a Spirit takes a known name (such as that of an apostle or a respected person) to fix the ideas of the evoker.

• If a Spirit who only preaches good were capable of consciously lying without any use, we would have to assume that it is an evil Spirit, which is not logical. The essential and exclusive objective of Spiritism is the moral improvement of humankind. A high moral message serves this purpose.

In short, judgment on a Spirit that communicates under a respectable name, but provides a A pure message, without contradictions and living up to expectations. (like Kardec), it must be done primarily by moral appreciation of language and maxims.

2. Betrayal Through Language

Kardec warned that spirits who appropriate respectable names as a form of mystification are quickly unmasked when their language is analyzed.

• The impostor spirits They betray themselves immediately through the language they use and the maxims they formulate.. If, for example, the Spirit offends common sense or morality, it will demonstrate, by that simple fact, the deception.

• Deceiving spirits can imitate anything, except true knowledge and true feeling..

• The language of truly good and superior Spirits is always dignified, noble, logical, and free from contradictions., and in it one breathes the wisdom, benevolence, and the purest morality.

• If a teaching is good, rational, and does not provoke serious objections, the conclusion is that the source is superior, even if the name is apocryphal.

3. When Identity is Crucial

Although identity is secondary for the general instruction, It is considered important or easier to verify in other contexts:

1. Intimate Evocations: If the goal is to communicate with a relative or friend, the same person It is of interest, and reasonable, to try to ascertain the identity, which is more easily proven when dealing with contemporary Spirits, whose characters and habits are known.

2. Systemic Mystifications: Attention should be focused on distinction between good and evil spirits, ...whose quality is never indifferent, even if individuality is. The spirit of a lower order that adorns itself with a respectable name so that its words may be believed requires great caution.

What Kardec demonstrated about the situation:

Allan Kardec demonstrated that continuous discernment, based on logic and common sense, It is the safest tool. He and the Parisian Society for Spiritualist Studies did not accept everything that came from the Spirits as irrefutable truth, knowing that they can be mistaken or mislead.

Experience (the continuous observation of facts and language) provides the means to unmask mystifications.

In summary, If the message from the spirit claiming to be Kardec is elevated and moral, then it is, by definition, useful for their moral advancement, which is the essential goal of Spiritism. In these cases, the quality of teaching This is sufficient proof that the Spirit is elevated (whether it be Kardec or a Spirit of equal elevation presenting themselves under that name). To prove the identity materially would be childish or unnecessary, since the value of the exchange would already be established by its moral content.

For better understanding, we can use an analogy: in Spiritist Doctrine, receiving a high moral message is like receiving a check signed by a highly reputable figure. If the check is genuinely endorsed by a solid financial institution (morality and reason), the validity of the message (the teaching) is guaranteed, even if you are not sure if the person who personally delivered it was the signatory, because the charitable intention and the source of value are undeniable. The focus is on... The undeniable value of the currency (its morality), and not the authenticity of the signature, is what determines its value.. The spirit of a lower order, in turn, would be like someone trying to pass a counterfeit bill, but the material (morality) does not withstand close inspection.

image_pdfimage_print

Reading Recommendations (Books)

Written by 

Leave a message

Your email address will not be published. Campos obrigatórios são marcados com *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.